fgemods: (Default)
fgemods ([personal profile] fgemods) wrote in [community profile] fandomgrowthexchange2017-08-01 06:43 pm
Entry tags:

Nominations Clean-Up & Review

Thank you all for nominating so many great tags! Everyone, please make sure that your nominations look correct, and let us know immediately if something doesn't look right.

 

Below are all of our tag migration questions. Please help us with these wandering tags and tell us which fandom(s) they were originally nominated under. If you spot any other wandering tags, please bring them to our attention.

Doctor Who
  • Eighth Doctor/Jack Harkness - currently in Doctor Who, Doctor Who (2005), Doctor Who (Big Finish Audio) We placed it in Doctor Who

Marvel
  • Stryfe & Nathan Summers - currently in Marvel 616, X-Force (Comics) and X-Men (Comicverse) We placed it in X-Men (Comicverse)

  • Theresa Cassidy/James Proudstar - currently in Marvel 616, X-Force (Comics), X-Men (Comicverse), X-Men (Alternate Timeline Movies) We placed it in X-Men (Comicverse)

  • Jubilation Lee/Logan (X-Men) - currently in X-Men ATM, X-Men OTM

  • Victor Creed/Logan - currently in X-Men OTM, Wolverine

  • Victor Creed/Remy LeBeau/Logan (X-Men) - currently in X-Men OTM, Wolverine

  • Theresa Cassidy & Wade Wilson - currently in Marvel 616, X-Men OTM, X-Men Comicverse, X-Force (Comics) We placed it in X-Men (Comicverse)



If we don't hear one way or the other before sign-ups open, we'll use our best judgment to place these relationships.


The following are all now fixed, thank you:
ASoIaF / Game of Thrones
  • The following are all currently in both ASoIaF and Game of Thrones:
    • Jon Connington/Ned Stark
    • Renly Baratheon & Brienne of Tarth
    • Renly Baratheon & Margaery Tyrell
    • Renly Baratheon & Robert Baratheon
    • Robert Baratheon & Stannis Baratheon
    • Salladhor Saan/Davos Seaworth
    • Stannis Baratheon & Maester Cressen
    • Stannis Baratheon/Ned Stark

BanG Dream!
  • The following are all currently in both BanG Dream! Girl's Band Party! (Video Game) and BanG Dream! (Anime):
    • Hanazono Tae/Ichigaya Arisa/Toyama
    • Kasumi/Ushigome Rimi/Yamabuki Saaya
    • Hanazono Tae/Ushigome Rimi
    • Ichigaya Arisa/Hanazono Tae
    • Ichigaya Arisa/Toyama Kasumi
    • Ichigaya Arisa/Yamabuki Saaya
    • Okusawa Misaki/Tsurumaki Kokoro
    • Shirokane Rinko/Udagawa Ako

X/1999 and/or Tokyo Babylon
  • The following are all currently in both X/1999 and Tokyo Babylon:
    • Lady Sumeragi & Sumeragi Subaru[*]
    • Monou Fuuma/Sumeragi Subaru
    • Sakura Tree/Sakurazuka Seishirou
    • Sakurazuka Seishirou & Sumeragi Hokuto
    • Sakurazuka Seishirou/Sakurazuka Setsuka
    • Sakurazuka Seishirou/Sumeragi Hokuto/Sumeragi Subaru
    [*] A disambiguated version of this particular ship is already in the tag set for Tokyo Babylon; was it also nominated under X/1999?

Fate/stay night and Related Fandoms
  • The following are all currently in both Fate/stay night and Related Fandoms and Fate/kaleid liner PRISMA ILLYA
    • Emiya Shirou/Arturia Pendragon | Saber/Tohsaka Rin
    • Emiya Shirou/Kotomine Kirei
    • Matou Sakura/Tohsaka Rin
    • Miyu Edelfelt/Chloe von Einzbern | Kuro/Illyasviel von Einzbern
    • Miyu Edelfelt/Illyasviel von Einzbern

Vampire Diaries
  • The following are currently in both The Vampire Diaries (TV) and The Originals (TV):
    • Elijah Mikaelson/Freya Mikaelson
    • Finn Mikaelson/Freya Mikaelson

Fruits Basket
  • The following are currently in both Fruits Basket and Fruits Basket - Takaya Natsuki (Manga):
      • Manabe Kakeru & Sohma Yuki
    • Manabe Kakeru/Sohma Yuki


(Anonymous) 2017-08-02 02:05 am (UTC)(link)
Not the nominator of X1999 and Tokyo Babylon, and I haven't read the comics in a long time, so I'm unsure about some of the characters, but Subaru and Seishirou definitely appear on both the titles.

I *think* that Fuuma only appears on X1999 and Hokuto only on TB, but I could be wrong. There's a chance that Fuuma made a guest appearance on TB and that Hokuto was on X1999 as a memory/flashback scenes, or mentioned in dialogues.

No idea about the rest of the characters. I'm really sorry, probably this isn't very helpful.

(Anonymous) 2017-08-02 02:13 am (UTC)(link)
Also:

•Jubilation Lee/Logan (X-Men) - currently in X-Men ATM, X-Men OTM
They appeared on both the timelines.

•Victor Creed/Logan - currently in X-Men OTM, Wolverine
They appeared on both the movie series.

•Victor Creed/Remy LeBeau/Logan (X-Men) - currently in X-Men OTM, Wolverine
Remy appeared on a Wolverine movie, that is part of the X-Men OTM anyway, afaik, so they could stay under both the fandom tags.

(Anonymous) 2017-08-02 02:43 am (UTC)(link)
For the fandom Blood Drive (TV), there are several nominations involving the character "Christopher Carson." According to IMDb, Christopher's last name should be Carpenter, not Carson.
plaid_slytherin: (Default)

[personal profile] plaid_slytherin 2017-08-02 03:34 am (UTC)(link)
I meant them for A Song of Ice and Fire. Sorry for not disambiguating!

(Anonymous) 2017-08-02 04:19 am (UTC)(link)
Not the nominator, but personally I'd put Eighth Doctor/Jack Harkness in the more general Doctor Who tag, since they haven't actually met yet, either on TV or in Big Finish, despite the two of them appearing in both.

(Anonymous) 2017-08-02 04:47 am (UTC)(link)
I'm not the nominator for these tags, but I'd say these go in Fate/stay night and related fandoms:
Emiya Shirou/Arturia Pendragon | Saber/Tohsaka Rin
Emiya Shirou/Kotomine Kirei
Matou Sakura/Tohsaka Rin

And these go in Fate/kaleid liner PRISMA ILLYA:
Miyu Edelfelt/Chloe von Einzbern | Kuro/Illyasviel von Einzbern
Miyu Edelfelt/Illyasviel von Einzbern

(Anonymous) 2017-08-02 05:22 am (UTC)(link)
Original nominator of these fandoms here.

For Fate & Related Fandoms, these go under Fate/kaleid liner PRISMA ILLYA:
  • Miyu Edelfelt/Chloe von Einzbern | Kuro/Illyasviel von Einzbern
  • Miyu Edelfelt/Illyasviel von Einzbern

  • For Bang Dream!:
    These should be under Bang Dream! (Anime):
  • Hanazono Tae/Ichigaya Arisa/Toyama
    Kasumi/Ushigome Rimi/Yamabuki Saaya
  • Hanazono Tae/Ushigome Rimi
  • Ichigaya Arisa/Hanazono Tae
  • Ichigaya Arisa/Toyama Kasumi
  • Ichigaya Arisa/Yamabuki Saaya
  • These go under BanG Dream! Girl's Band Party! (Video Game).
  • Okusawa Misaki/Tsurumaki Kokoro
  • Shirokane Rinko/Udagawa Ako

  • For nominations in Tokyo Babylon/X/1999:

    Tokyo Babylon is a prequel to X/1999. That's why many of the relationships crossed over. As an anon above said, Subaru and Seishirou are in both series. Fuuma is only in X/1999. Hokuto is not present in X/1999 but she is indeed mentioned in dialogues/flashbacks.

    For X/1999, my nominations were:
  • Monou Fuuma/Sumeragi Subaru
  • Sakura Tree/Sakurazuka Seishirou
  • Sakurazuka Seishirou/Sakurazuka Setsuka

  • For Tokyo Babylon, my nominations were:
  • Sakurazuka Seishirou & Sumeragi Hokuto
  • Sakurazuka Seishirou/Sumeragi Hokuto/Sumeragi Subaru

  • Yes, I nominated Lady Sumeragi & Sumeragi Subaru under both X/1999 and Tokyo Babylon.

    (Anonymous) 2017-08-02 10:07 am (UTC)(link)
    Just a minor typo under The Silmarillion 'Fingolfin | Ñolofinwë/Fingon | Findekáno/Maedhros | Maitmo' - Maitmo should be 'Maitimo'
    evilmuffins: (Default)

    [personal profile] evilmuffins 2017-08-02 12:25 pm (UTC)(link)
    Not the nominator, but the Fruits Basket ships are the exact same. I would keep the manga header since it has more nominated under it, and get rid of the just plain 'Fruits Basket' one.
    hithelleth: (Default)

    [personal profile] hithelleth 2017-08-02 03:45 pm (UTC)(link)
    The Vampire Diaries (TV) and The Originals (TV):
    Elijah Mikaelson/Freya Mikaelson
    Finn Mikaelson/Freya Mikaelson

    I nominated both relationships under The Originals (TV), I guess someone else nominated them under The Vampire Diaries. The Originals are a spin-off show from The Vampire Diaries; Elijah and Finn Mikaelson appear in both, but Freya is only mentioned (not even by name) in The Vampire Diaries, and only appears as an adult in The Originals, so personally I'd say the relationships fit more under The Originals.
    Edited 2017-08-02 15:46 (UTC)

    (Anonymous) 2017-08-02 05:51 pm (UTC)(link)
    Jubilation Lee/Logan (X-Men) -> X-Men (Comicverse)
    Victor Creed/Logan -> Wolverine (Movies)
    Victor Creed/Remy LeBeau/Logan (X-Men) -> Wolverine (Movies)

    (Anonymous) 2017-08-03 01:21 am (UTC)(link)
    Manabe Kakeru only appears in the manga version of Fruits Basket, not the anime adaptation, so the manga heading makes the most sense.