Follow-Up Questions & Clarifications Post

[fgemods]

Hi, lovely participants!

We have been loading relationships with your responses into the tagset and approvals of newly-nominated relationships will be ongoing. But we still need your help! If you've nominated in one of the following fandoms, please look through and see if your relationship(s) need clarification.

A few notes:

• Some relationships have been removed from the tagset. These relationships were either crossovers (ineligible for this year) or had a fic/author count over the limit. However, if you believe a relationship you nominated should not have been removed (or was forgotten), please comment here. You can also contact us via email or the page-a-mod post.


• Most of the relationships requiring clarification have not been migrated yet. Once we know where to place them, we will add them.


• Nominations officially close Friday, August 7th @ 11:55 PM UTC.


• We'll have a list of rejected nominations and the reasons after nominations are closed.

New Tagset + Nominate

Marvel

Fandoms:

1. Marvel (Comics)


2. Marvel 616


3. Marvel Noir


4. MCU


5. Secret Avengers


6. The Amazing Spider-Man (Movies - Webb)


7. Ultimate Spider-Man (Cartoon)


8. X-Force

---

Did you mean to nominate in Marvel Cinematic Universe or Marvel (Comics)?

• Maria Hill/Jasper Sitwell

Did you mean to nominate in Marvel Cinematic Universe, Marvel (Comics), Marvel 616, or Marvel Noir?

• Gamora/Tony Stark
• James "Bucky" Barnes/Pepper Potts
• Maria Hill/Pepper Potts/Natasha Romanov

Did you mean to nominate in Marvel Cinematic Universe, Marvel (Comics), or Marvel 616?

• Clint Barton/Sam Wilson
• Maria Hill/Bobbi Morse/Natasha Romanov
• Sharon Carter/Sam Wilson

Did you mean to nominate in Marvel Cinematic Universe or Marvel 616?

• Alexander Pierce/Arnim Zola
• Fandral/Loki/Sif
• Fandral/Sif
• Loki/Sif/Thor

Did you mean to nominate in Marvel (Comics) or Marvel 616?

• Loki & Victor von Doom
• Matt Murdock/Patsy Walker/Jennifer Walters
• Molly Hayes & Tommy Shepherd
• Natasha Romanov/Rogue (X-Men)
• Tony Stark/Jennifer Walters
• Wanda Maximoff/Victor von Doom

Did you mean to nominate in Marvel (Comics), Marvel 616, or Marvel Noir?

• Felicia Hardy/Gwen Stacy/Mary Jane Watson
• Felicia Hardy/Mary Jane Watson-Parker
• Gwen Stacy/Mary Jane Watson
• Matt Murdock & Jennifer Walters
• Matt Murdock/Jennifer Walters
• Wanda Maximoff & Tommy Shepherd

Did you mean to nominate in Marvel (Comics), Marvel 616, Marvel Noir, or X-Force?

• Felicia Hardy/Logan

Did you mean to nominate in Marvel Cinematic Universe, Marvel 616, Marvel (Comics) or Secret Avengers?

• Clint Barton/Phil Coulson/Nick Fury
• Phil Coulson/Nick Fury
• Sharon Carter/Maria Hill

Did you mean to nominate in Marvel (Comics) or Secret Avengers?

• Maria Hill/MODOK

Did you mean to nominate in Ultimate Spider-Man (Cartoon), Marvel Noir, Marvel 616, or Marvel (Comics)?

• Peter Parker/Flash Thompson

Did you mean to nominate in The Amazing Spider-Man (Movies - Webb), Ultimate Spider-Man (Cartoon), Marvel 616, or Marvel (Comics)?

• Harry Osborn/Flash Thompson

Did you mean to nominate in Marvel Noir, The Amazing Spider-Man (Movies - Webb), Ultimate Spider-Man (Cartoon), Marvel 616, or Marvel (Comics)?

• Harry Osborn/Peter Parker

Did you mean to nominate in Marvel Noir, The Amazing Spider-Man (Movies - Webb), Marvel 616, or Marvel (Comics)?

• Harry Osborn/Peter Parker/Gwen Stacy

Tolkien and Related Fandoms

Below you'll find our efforts to sort the Tolkien books nominations, as well as potential related All Media Types nominations.

Also, please remember that both characters must appear in the fandom for the relationship to qualify. If this means your nominated relationship must now go under the general TOLKIEN J. R. R. - Works tag, let us know.

The Hobbit - J.R.R. Tolkien

We're finding out some The Hobbit - All Media Types nominations were moved to the books, so please make sure these are right.

• Beorn & Gandalf (Hobbit)


• Bifur & Bofur & Bombur & Fíli & Kíli (Hobbit)


• Bifur & Kíli (Hobbit)


• Bilbo Baggins & Balin & Dwalin (Hobbit)


• Bilbo Baggins & Elrond (Hobbit)


• Bilbo Baggins & Gandalf (Hobbit)


• Bilbo Baggins & Thorin Oakenshield (Hobbit)


• Bilbo Baggins/Elrond (Hobbit)


• Bilbo Baggins/Gandalf (Hobbit)


• Bungo Baggins/Belladonna Took (Hobbit)


• Elrond & Thorin Oakenshield (Hobbit)


• Elrond/Gandalf (Hobbit)


• Lobelia Sackville-Baggins/Belladonna Took (Hobbit)

Lord of the Rings

• Aragorn & Elrond (LOTR)


• Aragorn & Faramir (LOTR)


• Aragorn/Arwen/Éowyn/Faramir (LOTR)


• Aragorn/Denethor (LOTR)


• Aragorn/Ecthelion II (LOTR)


• Aragorn/Glorfindel (LOTR)


• Aragorn/Halbarad (LotR)


• Aragorn/Theoden (LotR)


• Arwen & Arwen's Daughters (LOTR)


• Arwen & Celebrían (LOTR)


• Arwen & Galadriel (LOTR)


• Arwen/Éowyn (LotR)


• Arwen/Éowyn/Lothíriel (LotR)


• Arwen/Galadriel (LOTR)


• Arwen/Lothíriel (LotR)


• Celeborn & Elrond & Thranduil (LOTR)


• Celeborn & Elrond (LOTR)


• Celebrían & Galadriel (LOTR)


• Círdan/Gildor Inglorion (LOTR)


• Elfhild & Théodwyn (LOTR)


• Elladan/Elrohir/Legolas Greenleaf (LotR)


• Éomer/Éowyn (LOTR)


• Eowyn & Glorfindel (LOTR)


• Éowyn & Théodwyn (LOTR)


• Éowyn/Galadriel (LotR)


• Éowyn/Lothíriel (LotR)


• Erestor & Tom Bombadil (LOTR)


• Fimbrethil/Goldberry (LOTR)


• Finduilas of Dol Amroth/Ioreth (LOTR)


• Galadriel/Gimli (LOTR)


• Gilmith & Mithrellas (LOTR)


• Goldberry/Lady of the Blue Brooch (LotR)


• Imrazor/Mithrellas (LOTR)


• Lindir/Rúmil (LotR)

The Silmarillion and other histories of Middle-Earth - J.R.R. Tolkien

• Aerin/Morwen Eledhwen (Silmarillion)


• Almarian/Erendis (Silmarillion)


• Amras/Amrod/Caranthir/Celegorm/Curufin/Fëanor/Maedhros/Maglor (Silmarillion)


• Amras/Nellas (Silmarillion)


• Amroth/Nimrodel (Silmarillion)


• Anairë/Eärwen/Nerdanel (Silmarillion)


• Andreth/Galadriel (Silmarillion)


• Angrod/Eldalótë (Silmarillion)


• Aredhel & Eöl (Silmarillion)


• Aredhel & Fingolfin (Silmarillion)


• Aredhel & Írimë (Silmarillion)


• Aredhel & Maeglin (Silmarillion)


• Aredhel/Eöl/Meleth/Rôg (Silmarillion)


• Aredhel/Haleth (Silmarillion)


• Barahir (First Age)/Emeldir (Silmarillion)


• Beleg Cúthalion/Daeron (Silmarillion)


• Beleg Cúthalion/Mablung of Doriath (Silmarillion)


• Beleg Cúthalion/Nellas (Silmarillion)


• Bëor/Finrod (Silmarillion)


• Beren Erchamion/Finrod/Lúthien (Silmarillion)


• Caranthir/Caranthir's Wife (Silmarillion)


• Celebrimbor & Maeglin (Silmarillion)


• Celebrimbor & Narvi (Silmarillion)


• Celebrimbor/Curufin (Silmarillion)


• Celebrimbor/Finrod (Silmarillion)


• Celegorm/Curufin (Silmarillion)


• Celegorm/Finrod (Silmarillion)


• Curufin & Finrod (Silmarillion)


• Curufin & Maglor (Silmarillion)


• Curufin/Maedhros (Silmarillion)


• Curufin/Maglor (Silmarillion)


• Daeron/Maglor (Silmarillion)


• Egalmoth/Eöl (Silmarillion)


• Elemmírë/Findis (Silmarillion)


• Elemmírë/Írimë (Silmarillion)


• Elrond & Maglor (Silmarillion)


• Elrond/Elros/Maedhros/Maglor (Silmarillion)


• Emeldir/Lúthien (Silmarillion)


• Faniel & Findis & Írimë (Silmarillion)


• Fëanor & Fingolfin (Silmarillion)


• Fëanor/Indis (Silmarillion)


• Fëanor/Maedhros (Silmarillion)


• Fëanor/Maedhros/Nerdanel (Silmarillion)


• Finduilas Faelivrin/Lúthien (Silmarillion)


• Fingolfin & Fingon (Silmarillion)


• Fingolfin & Hador Lórindol (Silmarillion)


• Fingolfin/Fingon (Silmarillion)


• Fingon & Turgon (Silmarillion)


• Fingon/Fingon's Wife (Silmarillion)


• Fingon/Fingon's Wife/Maedhros (Silmarillion)


• Fingon/Finrod/Maedhros (Silmarillion)


• Finrod/Galadriel (Silmarillion)


• Finrod/Maedhros (Silmarillion)


• Finrod/Maglor (Silmarillion)


• Galadriel/Lúthien (Silmarillion)


• Galadriel/Melian (Silmarillion)


• Galadriel/Varda (Silmarillion)


• Gildis/Hador Lórindol (Silmarillion)


• Glóredhel/Hareth (Silmarillion)


• Haldar's Wife/Haleth (Silmarillion)


• Haleth/Lalwen (Silmarillion)


• Huor/Rían of the House of Bëor (Silmarillion)


• Idril Celebrindal/Meleth (Silmarillion)


• Idril Celebrindal/Nimloth (Silmarillion)


• Idril Celebrindal/Rían of the House of Bëor (Silmarillion)


• Ilmarë/Thuringwethil (Silmarillion)


• Indis/Míriel (Silmarillion)


• Lúthien/Thuringwethil (Silmarillion)


• Maglor/Sauron (Silmarillion)


• Meleth/Rôg (Silmarillion)


• Melian/Morwen Eledhwen (Silmarillion)


• Nellas/Niënor Níniel (Silmarillion)


• Nessa/Tar-Vanimeldë (Silmarillion)


• Niënor Níniel/Túrin Turambar (Silmarillion)


• Orodreth/Orodreth's Wife (Silmarillion)


• Tar-Míriel/Uinen (Silmarillion)

 

Final Fantasy

Below you'll find our efforts to sort the Final Fantasy nominations. Also, please remember that both characters must appear in the fandom for the relationship to qualify. If this means your nominated relationship must now go under the general Final Fantasy tag, let us know. We have two suggestions to combine X, X-2, and FF X/X-2. Are there any objections?

Final Fantasy (general/umbrella tag)

• Garland/Kuja (All Types)


• Tidus/Wakka (All Types)

Final Fantasy VI

• Celes Chere & Locke Cole


• Celes Chere/Edgar Roni Figaro


• Celes Chere/Kefka Palazzo


• Celes Chere/Leo Christophe


• Celes Chere/Leo Christophe/Kefka Palazzo


• Celes Chere/Locke Cole/Setzer Gabbiani


• Celes Chere/Macías "Mash" Rene Figaro | Celes Chere/Sabin Rene Figaro


• Celes Chere/Rachel


• Celes Chere/Setzer Gabbiani


• Gestahl/Kefka


• Locke Cole/Phoenix


• Locke Cole/Setzer Gabbiani


• Macías "Mash" Rene Figaro/Shadow | Sabin Rene Figaro/Shadow


• Terra Branford/Leo Christophe/Kefka Palazzo


• Tina Branford/Cayenne Garamonde | Terra Branford/Cyan Garamonde


• Tina Branford/Celes Chere/Locke Cole | Terra Branford/Celes Chere/Locke Cole


• Tina Branford/Kefka Palazzo | Terra Branford/Kefka Palazzo


• Tina Branford/Setzer Gabbiani | Terra Branford/Setzer Gabbiani

Final Fantasy IX

• Amarant Coral/Freya Crescent/Zidane Tribal


• Amarant Coral/Lani


• Amarant Coral/Zidane Tribal


• Beatrix/Freya Crescent


• Beatrix/Kuja


• Blank/Marcus


• Blank/Ruby


• Blank/Zidane Tribal


• Brahne Raza Alexandros XVI/Beatrix


• Brahne/Kuja


• Freya Crescent/Sir Fratley


• Freya Crescent/Zidane Tribal


• Garnet til Alexandros XVII/Beatrix/Adelbert Steiner


• Garnet til Alexandros XVII/Kuja


• Garnet til Alexandros XVII/Marcus


• Garnet til Alexandros XVII/Ruby


• General Beatrix/Adelbert Steiner


• Lani/Adelbert Steiner


• Zidane Tribal/Blank/Ruby

Final Fantasy X

• Auron/Braska/Jecht


• Auron/Wen Kinoc


• Gatta/Luzzu


• Issaru/Yuna


• Lulu/Luzzu/Wakka


• Lulu/Rikku


• Luzzu/Wakka


• Seymour Guado/Yuna

Final Fantasy X-2

• Nooj/Paine

Final Fantasy X Final Fantasy X-2

• Auron/Yuna


• Baralai/Gippal/Nooj/Paine


• Brother/Yuna


• Gippal/Rikku


• Lulu/Yuna


• Paine/Rikku


• Paine/Rikku/Yuna


• Rikku/Tidus


• Rikku/Tidus/Yuna


• Rikku/Yuna

 

Kingdom Hearts

Remaining clarifications needed.

• Master Xehanort/Terra


• Namine/Sora


• Riku Replica/Sora


• Sora/Vanitas


• Sora/Young Xehanort


• Terra/Xehanort

We have a nomination for Daisy Duck/Donald Duck for Kingdom Hearts. Is that correct?
 

World Wrestling Entertainment & NXT

Could the nominator(s) tell us which fandom you wanted these under, WWE or NXT?

• Antonio Cesaro/Sami Zayn | El Generico


• Antonio Cesaro/Tyson Kidd/Natalya Neidhart


• Emma/Corey Graves | Sterling James Keenan


• Enzo Amore/Carmella/Colin Cassady


• John Morrison | Johnny Nitro/Ricochet | Prince Puma


• Kevin Steen/Sami Zayn | El Generico

William Shakespeare

These relationships appear under William Shakespeare - All Media Types, which is a non-canonical tag. We believe these were edited by the former mod. Please let us know how you originally nominated them.

• Douglas/Hotspur (Henry IV - PI)
• Mistress Quickly/Doll Tearsheet (Henry IV - PII)


• Mistress Quickly/Pistol (Henry IV - PII)


• Prince Hal (Shakespeare)/Henry "Hotspur" Percy (Henry IV - PI)


• Prince Hal (Shakespeare)/Henry "Hotspur" Percy/Kate Percy (Henry IV - PI)


• Sir John Falstaff/Doll Tearsheet (Henry IV - PII)


• Sir John Falstaff/Justice Shallow (Henry IV - PII)


• Sir John Falstaff/Prince Hal (Shakespeare) (Henry IV - PI)


• Sir John Falstaff/Prince Hal (Shakespeare)/Edward "Ned" Poins (Henry IV - PI)

Alliance-Union - C. J. Cherryh

To the nominator of this fandom, could you please consider nominating some relationships underneath it? The fandom by itself is not eligible for the exchange, but relationships underneath it may be eligible. Anyone else may also nominate eligible relationships for this fandom to get it approved.

Miscellaneous: DCU, Dragon Age, Harry Potter

A few miscellaneous questions!

• We believe we've properly sorted the Dragon Age nominations. Do they look correct?


• We believe we've properly sorted the DCU nominations. Do they look correct?

• Cassandra Cain/Harleen Quinzel (DC Super Hero Girls) - These versions of the characters do not appear in this subfandom? If we don't hear back from the nominator before the tagset closes, we'll move it to DCU (Comics).

• If you nominated any Harry Potter relationship for the Movies rather than the books, please let us know and we will get your nominations moved over.

Comments

[wallwalker]

If we're only considering the nominated Final Fantasy fandoms, then I would place Garland/Kuja in FFIX and Tidus/Wakka in FFX and FFX-2. (And yes, I would absolutely continue to advise combining them.)

[fgemods]

Thank you! That's good to know.

[(Anonymous)]

I'm not sure as I'm not the nommer, but I think there are some pairings under Young Justice (Comics) that were meant to go under Young Justice (Cartoon). I could recall this wrong but I don't think Wally was ever in the YJ comics as he was a founder member of Teen Titans in the comic verse; however he definitely was in the cartoon.

[fgemods]

Good catch! We'll look into this more closely.

[redleaderfic]

Enzo Amore/Carmella/Colin Cassady : NXT
Kevin Steen/Sami Zayn | El Generico : NXT

John Morrison | Johnny Nitro/Ricochet | Prince Puma : Neither, that should be under Lucha Underground

[fgemods]

Thank you!

[fgemods]

Are you the nominator?

Both of the NXT pairings are also eligible in WWE, thus our question.

The last one is a crossover between WWE/Lucha Underground and I don't see any nominations for Lucha Underground. Did you nominate that fandom and it got merged into WWE on the old tagset?

[redleaderfic]

Are you the nominator? Both of the NXT pairings are also eligible in WWE, thus our question.

I am! (Although I think that particular nom came from the previous round.) 99% percent of their interactions have been as part of NXT, so I thought that was a better fit.

The last one is a crossover between WWE/Lucha Underground and I don't see any nominations for Lucha Underground. Did you nominate that fandom and it got merged into WWE on the old tagset?

It's not a crossover at all though, AO3 seems to not want to create tags for Johnny Mundo, John Morrison/Johnny's Nitro's current name, and keeps migrating it to the names he used in WWE. (It's the same thing with Kevin Owens, everything keeps merging with Kevin Steen, a name he's not used since coming to NXT/WWE.) Johnny/Puma is a completely Lucha Underground pairing, they had a long feud there

I have Lucha Underground on my nomination sheet as an approved fandom, but the other approved pairing I nominated for it, Angélico/Matt Cross | Son of Havoc/Ivelisse Vélez, looks like it got merged into the WWE tag set too.

[fgemods]

Oooh! I see what happened then. Good to know and thank you. There was a lot of merging categories in the old tagset that led us to start the new one. I'll get this updated.

[(Anonymous)]

What kind of clarifications do you need for the Kingdom Hearts pairings?

[fgemods]

After further research there is apparently a line of Young Justice comics where Wally West appears as Kid Flash that is based on the animated TV show. I am not a DCU fan/reader myself, but if he shows up somewhere in the comics, then he is eligible.

[fgemods]

We're hoping the person who nominated the relationships will confirm that they wanted those under Kingdom Hearts. With all the shifting done to the original tagset, we can't be certain everything was in the right place.

But if the original nominator can't chime in, we'd like confirmation that both characters in the relationship appear in Kingdom Hearts</em -- or if that relationship would be better suited for a different fandom.

[(Anonymous)]

I'm not the nominator for all of them, but I can confirm all those pairings are of characters that appear only in Kingdom Hearts and couldn't be from any other fandom.

[fgemods]

Thank you! We'll load those nominations with our next batch!