Nominations Clarifications & Questions - 1

[fgemods]

Tagset | Evidence Post | Rejected Noms

Nominations have been going smoothly! Take a moment to check if we've asked about one of your nominations below. Also, a couple quick reminders: when nominating characters, do so in the form "Character & None". In addition, disambiguating is not required, but it can be particularly helpful for us if there are interconnected or umbrella canons.

Crossing Jordan

• Jordan Cavanaugh/Woody Hoyt - This ship has 11 fics and 8 authors after filters, but since it's so close, we wanted to double-check if we missed something before rejecting it.

Teen Wolf

• Chris Argent/Melissa McCall - This ship has 100+ fics when filtered for English and complete. They do not appear to be the primary ship in most of them, but we’d like help making sure. Could the nominator point out the 10 or fewer fics (or 5 or fewer authors who’ve written fics) that do focus on the relationship?

Winter's Orbit

• Jainan nav Adessari/Kiem Tegnar - This tag is an odd case to judge, in that The Course of Honor (the title when it was on AO3) is synned to Original Works rather than Winter's Orbit. The ship has 20 fics when we include fics written for it when it was on AO3 as The Course of Honour. Is Winter's Orbit's depiction of these characters distinct enough to be counted separately?

The World of Black Hammer (Comics)

• Skulldigger & Matthew - We're having trouble verifying the existence of the character "Matthew" in this canon in online sources.  Please verify that this is the correct name.

Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008)- All Media Types

• Arla Fett/Bo-Katan Kryze, Arla Fett/Satine Kryze - Arla Fett does not seem to appear in The Clone Wars. Would the nominator(s) like to change the canon to Star Wars - All Media Types?
• Satine Kryze/Tarre Vizsla - Tarre Vizsla does not seem to appear in The Clone Wars. Would the nominator like to change the canon to Star Wars - All Media Types?

Star Wars: Clone Wars (2003) - All Media Types

• CC-2224 | Cody/Obi-Wan Kenobi/CT-7567 | Rex, CT-7567 | Rex/Anakin Skywalker - Rex does not seem to appear in Clone Wars (2003). Would the nominator(s) like to change the canon?
• Mace Windu/CC-3636 | Wolffe, Plo Koon/CC-3636 | Wolffe - Wolffe does not seem to appear in Clone Wars (2003). Would the nominator(s) like to change the canon?

Comments

[klutzygirl]

Oh, Jordan/Woody on Crossing Jordan had ten fics at the time I submitted but someone must have posted a new fic since then. Will edit!

Will also fix Chris Argent/Melissa McCall!

[delphi]

The World of Black Hammer (Comics)
• Skulldigger & Matthew

I had a feeling this one might be tough to verify, sorry about that! Matthew is a main character in the Skulldigger + Skeleton Boy miniseries, but we only learn his name in one panel near the very end. He's got an entry in the League of Comic Geeks lookup under that name, if it helps: Dark Horse -> World of Black Hammer -> Matthew

[fgemods]

Thank you, it's been added to the tagset.

[delphi]

Thanks!

[morbane]

Winter's Orbit
Jainan nav Adessari/Kiem Tegnar - This tag is an odd case to judge, in that The Course of Honor (the title when it was on AO3) is synned to Original Works rather than Winter's Orbit. The ship has 20 fics when we include fics written for it when it was on AO3 as The Course of Honour. Is Winter's Orbit's depiction of these characters distinct enough to be counted separately?

I am not the nominator but have read both and consider them distinct - there are many plot and setting changes that also affect the development of the relationship even though the relationship and characters have very similar arc.

[fgemods]

Thanks, that's very helpful insight; we've approved the Winter's Orbit nom.