Rejected Nominations Post

[fgemods]

The following nominations were rejected for the reason provided. If you feel we rejected your nomination in error, feel free to comment below; if we have made a mistake, the tag can be reinstated.

If you are nominating a fandom, character or relationship that may appear ineligible, but it has not been rejected by us yet, please see the Evidence Post.

11+ Works by 6+ Authors

These did not meet the criteria for 10 or fewer works/5 or fewer authors on AO3, filtered by complete and in English and appearing in the requested fandom.

• Luna Lovegood/Severus Snape in Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling
• Linhardt von Hevring/Claude von Riegan in Fire Emblem: Fuukasetsugetsu | Fire Emblem: Three Houses
• Axel/Kairi (Kingdom Hearts) in Kingdom Hearts (Video Games)
• Helena Campbell/Valentine in Mirrormask (2005)
• Sylas/Lux (Leage of Legends) in League of Legends
• Eurydice/Hades (Hadestown) in Hadestown - Mitchell
• Esmeralda/Claude Frollo in Notre-Dame de Paris | The Hunchback of Notre-Dame - Victor Hugo
• Oliver Banks/Graham Folger in The Magnus Archives (podcast)
• Calamity Jane/Katie Brown in Calamity Jane (1953)
• Irving Braxiatel & Leela & Narvin & Romana II (Gallifrey) in Gallifrey (Big Finish Audio)
• Hughie Campbell/The Homelander | John in The Boys (TV 2019)
• Leah Clearwater/Bella Swan in Twilight Series - All Media Types
• Ray Gillette/Algernop Krieger in Archer (Cartoon)
• Ashiya Shirou | Alciel/Maou Sadao | Satan Jacob in Hataraku Maou-Sama! | The Devil Is a Part-Timer!

Not Canon Characters

One or more of the included characters does not appear to be canonical.

• Fiona McKee & Original Female Character(s) (Your Honor TV 2020) in Your Honor (TV 2020)
• Mercury (Shining Nikki)/Original Female Character(s) (Shining Nikki) in 闪耀暖暖 | Shining Nikki (Video Game)
• Kane/Original Male Character (Papercut) in Papercut (2018)
• Nigel Townsend/Original Female Character(s) (Crossing Jordan) in Crossing Jordan
• Wednesday Addams & OFC in Adult Wednesday Addams (Web Series)
• Wednesday Addams & OMC in Adult Wednesday Addams (Web Series)
• Wednesday Addams/OMC in Adult Wednesday Addams (Web Series)
• Archibald Haddock/Tintin (Adventures of Tintin (2011))
• Any & Any, Any/Any and Pietro Maximoff & Wanda Maximoff in Marvel Future Revolution (Mobile Game)

Mix of / and & Relationships

These are tags that include both & and / relationships.

•   Maurynna Kyrissean/Linden Rathan & Bard Otter in The Last Dragonlord - Joanne Bertin

Comments

[polyalice]

Hi, sorry to bug you again but I saw Eurydice/Hades was denied. I got curious and realized I didn't really expand on the evidence because of the otp:true. I just wanted to rectify that and add a few more links.

Fandom: Hadestown
Character/Relationship: Eurydice/Hades
Evidence of Eligibility:
This is Persephone/Hades It only mentions Eurydice by name, she doesn’t even have much-if any-dialogue.
This one is more Eurydice/Orpheos and Hades/Persephone Eurydice and Hades only talk once in the fic.

This would bring it down to ten but I got curious, not entirely sure if this was allowed in the rules, but I excluded Persephone/Hades since that was showing up a lot and I got six.

[fgemods]

Hi, thank you for the helpful links and explanation. The tag has been added to the tagset now.

Just to explain, we typically don't use the exclusion of other ships when determining eligibility since, with the way AO3 works, that could exclude valid ships for the fic. For instance, there appears to be a fic about Eurydice/Hades that only has Hades/Persephone tagged because it is mentioned.

Hope that helps!

[polyalice]

Awesome! Thanks for the clarification/help and sorry to be such a hassle. (・・；)

[angstythumbs]

Last Dragonlord --
Could it be changed to the following?

Maurynna Kyrissean & Linden Rathan & Bard Otter in The Last Dragonlord - Joanne Bertin

[fgemods]

It's added now!

[angstythumbs]

Thank you!